Review: Nokia adds VoIP to business handset

The Nokia E51 fits the business essentials into a slim handset with IP telephony support

Written by Daniel Robinson

Larger Image

Nokia’s E51 handset is aimed squarely at business users, offering email access and advanced capabilities such as IP telephony over Wi-Fi, yet delivers this in a slimline and unobtrusive design in keeping with Nokia’s traditional candybar phone products. However, we were unable to test the E51’s IP telephony functions, so firms interested in this need to carefully evaluate that it works with their infrastructure.

Available since October 2007, the E51 blends smartphone features with those of a standard handset. It runs Nokia’s S60 3rd Edition SP1 user environment atop the Symbian OS 9.2 platform, and supports high-speed HSDPA 3G networks and 802.11g Wi-Fi capability, as well as quad-band GSM for voice calls.

Despite this, it weighs just 100g, so can easily be slipped into a pocket, and apart from its 2in colour display it could be just a conventional phone.

The design of the phone should make the E51 appeal to firms looking for a handset to standardise on for mobile workers, especially organisations considering IP telephony for calls made on-campus in the future. In this respect, the E51 is similar to HP’s iPaq 514 Voice Messenger, which we tested last year.

As part of Nokia’s corporate E series, the E51 has much in common with other phones in the range, such as the E61. But while several of these have a qwerty keyboard, the E51 instead has a standard numeric keypad, making it less suitable for heavy email and messaging use, and more of a voice-focused device.

We found the E51 easy to use, at least when accessing most features that workers will typically need on a regular basis. Configuring the device is a different matter however, with a host of different settings that need entering in numerous places in the menu for features such as Wi-Fi, email and internet telephony. Fortunately, Nokia enables IT managers to remotely provision most of these settings for employees using its Intellisync Device Management tool.

For example, we found it a chore to set up the E51 to send and receive email, largely because the numeric keypad makes it a long-winded process to key in email addresses. In fairness to Nokia, the E51 comes with a setup wizard that automatically discovered most settings after we filled in our email address, but HP’s iPaq 514 ships with a Windows configuration tool that let us enter settings on a PC, then transfer them over via a USB connection. Out of the box, the E51 supports Microsoft’s ActiveSync protocol for getting push email from Exchange servers, plus Imap and POP3 for other mail accounts.

We experienced some difficulties with the E51’s Wi-Fi interface, and found that the phone would regularly lose its connection with our test wireless access point. This is a problem we have previously encountered with other Nokia handsets, but in this case it was solved by switching to a different access point that was not hidden. We would advise IT departments interested in the E51 for this feature to test it with their wireless infrastructure before deployment.

Users can connect to a Wi-Fi network relatively easily by scanning with a tool provided on the home screen. If it finds a previously defined access point, the user can proceed directly to browsing the web using that connection; otherwise it will prompt for the access point’s password, and then automatically add it to the access point list. Users can also manually add access points using the Settings tool.

Aside from the phone’s standard voice call features, the E51 also supports IP telephony using the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP), enabling calls to be made over Wi-Fi. This can be configured so that the phone automatically makes a voice-over-IP call whenever a Wi-Fi connection is available, or to let staff choose which transport to use.

Sadly, we were unable to test IP telephony on the E51 as we could not get this feature operating in the time available for testing, even with assistance from Nokia. The feature requires a SIP profile to be created to hook up with a PBX or server providing voice services, and this needs a long list of parameters, much more
than with HP’s iPaq 514, for example, which we were able to make IP calls on.

However, our review unit featured a number of tools that are also likely to prove beneficial to enterprise users. The most notable is Team Suite, a collaboration tool that lets the user maintain a list of colleagues, and set up a conference call with several or all of them at once, plus send messages to them. There is also a Search tool akin to Google’s desktop search that enables you to quickly find information in contacts, notes, calendar entries, appointments and emails on the phone.

Nokia also ships the Quickoffice mobile productivity suite that supports Microsoft Word, Excel and PowerPoint document formats. The version included on the E51 only supports viewing of files, but users can purchase and download an upgrade to full editing capability. Other applications include Nokia Maps, which can be used for navigation when combined with a Bluetooth GPS receiver, and various media players.

The screen of the E51 reveals that this is not just a standard handset, and fits a 240x320 display into its 2in area. We found this bright and sharp, making it easy to read. Although small, it gives a reasonable experience when using the Nokia web browser to view pages. The browser itself renders web pages very well for a mobile product, but we found we had to pan and zoom a great deal.

In our tests, we found web pages loaded quickly when we had a connection to a 3G data network or a Wi-Fi access point, but this slowed considerably if a standard GPRS connection was the only one available, which will be the situation for many users away from metropolitan areas.

Our review handset itself was stylish in design, with a metallic trim and a slide-off metal cover for the battery compartment at the rear. This is also where the SIM card slot and a slot for MicroSD Flash cards are found. The phone also boasts a 2 megapixel digital camera, and ships with a USB PC sync cable and wired headset for making calls.

Battery life is quoted at up to 4.4 hours of talk time, and up to 13 days on standby.

Tags:

Product overview

  • Price: £260 (SIM-free)
  • Web site: Nokia

Ratings

  • Our rating: 3
  • Average user rating:

Verdict

Nokia’s E51 makes a good business phone for users for whom voice calls are most important, but who also want to check their email. Its Wi-Fi capability makes it possible to make IP voice calls, but we were unable to test this and potential buyers should carefully evaluate compatibility with their network infrastructure.

PROS: Slim and light; Wi-Fi and VoIP capable

CONS: Wi-Fi exhibits quirks; tricky to configure

Best prices

reader comments

related articles

Review: Mini BlackBerry adds Wi-Fi support

RIM’s BlackBerry 8120 is more compact than other models, but compromises on its keypad 23 Nov 2007

 

Business review: HTC S710 smartphone

Trim Windows smartphone hides a slide-out qwerty keyboard but lacks 3G capability 23 Mar 2007

Business review: iPhone out of touch with business needs

The iPhone has an impressive user interface but lacks key features for corporate use 17 Dec 2007

New HP iPaqs offer 'gliding' optical control

Voice Messenger and Data Messenger devices offer five-way optical navigation sensor 21 Oct 2008

New Nokia phones separate work and leisure

New E-series handsets come with business tools and separate screens for home use 16 Jun 2008

Nokia 'iPhone killer' specs leaked

N96 'multimedia computer' expected to cost €550 13 Feb 2008

today's top stories

Solid as a rock - business continuity in a global manufacturer

From power supply problems in Nigeria to email availability in Stockport, PZ Cussons is prepared for anything 02 Dec 2008

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

IT staff desperate to keep their jobs

Most would work longer hours for less pay 02 Dec 2008

VMware View 3 enhances virtual desktops

Virtual clients now take up less storage space and can be 'checked out' to a laptop 02 Dec 2008

Technology and privacy

Watch part one of a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 01 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Will the terrorist attacks in Mumbai affect your offshoring plans?

Is India becoming a risky destination?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Padlocked CDVideo

Technology and privacy

Watch the final video in a two-part Computing roundtable debate on the importance of putting data privacy issues at the heart of your IT plans 02 Dec 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - Standard Life's offshoring plans; and the prospects for government IT

The insurance giant outlines its new outsourcing strategy; and we ask if the government's economic bailout will affect its IT plans 28 Nov 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Parcel being packedFeatures

Case study: eSpares and business continuity

Online electricals business has managed to decrease its downtime 02 Dec 2008

Royal Blackburn HospitalFeatures

NHS trust recovers from server overdose

Virtualisation technology breathed new life into East Lancashire's cost-intensive system 02 Dec 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation