Green advert

Advertising watchdog gives thumbs up to carbon intensity advert

Complaints over EDF advert claiming a 60 per cent cut in carbon intensity rejected

Written by James Murray

The term "carbon intensity" can be used in adverts promoting firms' green credentials, as long as it is clearly defined or equated to absolute carbon reductions, according to a new ruling from the UK's advertising watchdog.

The adjudication came in response to complaints received by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) over a TV advert from energy giant EDF which claimed the company aimed to "reduce the carbon intensity of CO2 emissions from their electricity productions by 60 per cent". The voiceover was accompanied by on-screen text claiming "aims based on improvements to EDF Energy's 2006 performance and is subject to change in the event of matters beyond EDF Energy's reasonable control".

The advert resulted in five complaints from viewers challenging whether the 60 per cent claim was misleading, as most viewers would not understand the term carbon intensity and would believe EDF intended to cut absolute emissions by 60 per cent.

In its response EDF argued that carbon intensity, whereby energy firms measure their emissions per unit of electricity, was an increasingly popular form of measurement in the energy sector that allowed for better comparison between rival operators and provided firms with the ability to track their performance, even if demand for electricity increases, for example as a result of wider adoption of electric vehicles.

It also claimed that while terms such as carbon intensity might not yet be fully understood by everyone, that should not prevent it being used to raise awareness of the issues, adding that the EDF web site contained a full glossary of that and other terms that might be less well understood by their customers.

Furthermore, the company said that the advert had not attempted "to artificially inflate their commitment claim" and that its analysis could have reasonably justified the claim that it was aiming to cut carbon intensity by 67 per cent. As such, the company said it also expects absolute emission to fall by 61 per cent on 2006 levels by 2020.

Consequently, the ASA rejected the complaints on the grounds that viewers were unlikely to be misled regardless of how they interpreted the claim.

A spokeswoman for the ASA said that the ruling would provide a precedent for advertisers, observing that the term carbon intensity could be reasonably used in adverts as long as it is clearly defined or used in a way where claims relating to targets can also be applied to absolute carbon reduction goals.

reader comments

related articles

 

ExxonMobil mulls appeal against green ad ban

Advertising watchdog rules that ad claiming liquefied natural gas was "one of the world's cleanest fuels" was unintentionally misleading 03 Sep 2008

Goodyear to refund customers over "greenwash" claims

Australian ad watchdog joins worldwide clampdown on firms exaggerating their green credentials 27 Jun 2008

Lexus ad banned over hybrid SUV claims

Claim that SUV which emits 192g of CO2 per km made "environmental, and economic, sense" slammed by watchdog 24 Sep 2008

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Hands on with the Windows 7 beta

When Microsoft demonstrated the features of Windows 7 at its professional developer conference (PDC) last year, I couldn't wait to try it... 09 Jan 2009

Going for gold in IT performance

Tom Young talks to London 2012’s chief integrator about the challenges involved in the world’s largest sports-related IT contract 08 Jan 2009

Nine priorities for 2009

Computing editor Bryan Glick looks at the workplace trends, policy issues, business drivers and technological developments that are most likely to influence IT agendas in the year ahead 07 Jan 2009

Panning for data gold - a guide to information management

Progressive IT chiefs are teaming up with business leaders to provide users with compelling new ways to sift through and make sense of corporate data 06 Jan 2009

Using business process management to thrive through the downturn

Our panel of experts discuss how to bridge the IT-business gap 06 Jan 2009

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Should the government cut costs by scrapping major IT projects?

Should the government cut costs by scrapping major IT projects?

Tell us what you think

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - the highlights of 2008

The Computing team pick their personal favourites of the year 18 Dec 2008

Xperia X1Video

Video Review: Sony Ericsson Xperia X1

First Looks Editor Ian Williams gets hands on with the Sony Ericsson Xperia X1 12 Dec 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Ramalinga RajuNews

Satyam fraud likely to trigger new regulation

Scandal may result in a similar outcome to that of Enron 08 Jan 2009

Gareth MorganComment

Trimming the fat of underachievement

The belt-tightening going on across the IT industry means it is vital to address any poor performers and strengthen the team dynamic 08 Jan 2009

Advertisement

Primary Navigation